The Art of Recruiting Sales Rockstars: Tips and Tricks - Amplify Group
Our Insights

The Art of Recruiting Sales Rockstars: Tips and Tricks - Amplify Group

June 19, 2023
Read Time:

Recruiting top talent for your sales team can be a daunting challenge. You need people who can sell your products or services to potential customers, and that requires unique skills, experience, and personality traits unique to your industry, product, customer, and company culture. As a founder or CEO, you know that your sales team is the backbone of your business, and you want to make sure you are hiring the best people for the job. In this blog post, I will share my top tips on how to recruit top sales talent and build a winning sales team.

Determine the role you need to hire for

It’s important to start by understanding the type of sales rep(s) you need. Let’s go over the different types of roles:

  • Sales Development Representative (SDR): SDRs focus on generating leads and qualifying prospects. Their primary responsibility is to reach out to potential customers, nurture initial relationships, and schedule meetings or demos for account executives. SDRs typically work closely with marketing teams to identify and pursue leads.
  • Account Executive (AE): Account executives are responsible for managing and closing deals with prospects. They engage in direct sales conversations, conduct product demonstrations, negotiate contracts, and work towards meeting sales quotas. AEs often develop and maintain long-term relationships with clients, providing ongoing support and upselling opportunities.
  • Sales Manager (Director or VP of Sales): Sales managers oversee a team of sales professionals. Their role involves setting sales targets, providing training, and coaching to the team, monitoring performance metrics, and ensuring the team achieves its objectives. They also play a crucial role in strategizing and executing sales plans.
  • Sales Operations or Revenue Operations (RevOps): Sales operations professionals focus on optimizing the sales process and supporting the sales team. They manage sales tools and technologies, analyze data and sales metrics, improve sales processes, and provide valuable insights to enhance efficiency and productivity.
  • Sales Engineer (aka Solutions Consultant or Solutions Architect):: Sales engineers combine technical knowledge with sales skills. They assist account executives in explaining the technical aspects of a product or service to customers, addressing any technical questions or concerns, and demonstrating how the solution meets the client's needs. They work closely with both the sales and product development teams.
  • Customer Success Manager: While not strictly a sales role, customer success managers and leaders work closely with sales teams to ensure customer satisfaction and retention. They build and nurture relationships with existing customers, provide support and guidance, identify upselling or cross-selling opportunities, and drive customer loyalty and long-term value.

Start by evaluating your existing teams’ strengths and weaknesses to determine where you need more support. For example, is your existing team great at closing, but needs more top of funnel leads? Then you might need an SDR. Or do you have a strong top of funnel now, and need more help converting leads? Then you might need an AE or sales operations professional.  

Define your Ideal Candidate Profile

Before you start recruiting, it's essential to define what your ideal sales candidate looks like, your Ideal Candidate Profile. This is akin to defining your Ideal Customer Profile for your target customers. Think about the skills and qualifications that you believe are necessary for the candidate to have success in your industry. Consider factors like education, experience, and soft skills, such as communication and problem-solving.

Ask yourself questions like:

  1. Have they sold to enterprise or SMB? Is that in line with your Ideal Customer Profile (ICP) or target buyer?
  2. If your ICP is enterprise customers, have they managed a complex sale with multiple buyers, or will that be a new challenge for them? Selling to an enterprise is a significantly more complex sale with multiple people in the buying center, and a significantly longer sales cycle.
  3. What industry/buyer have they sold to in the past? Does their experience align with your target market? Do they intimately understand how to sell to a Head of HR, Head of Data Science etc.
  4. Have they worked at a startup before, where product-market fit is an evolving process? Do they have the ability and agility to thrive in this kind of ambiguous and rapid change environment?
  5. Are they process oriented? As an early stage or emerging growth company, things are changing all the time, is this person detail oriented, good at documenting repeatable processes, good at collaborating with multiple teams internally? You’ll want someone who can document what works, what doesn’t, and build a repeatable scalable process for your continued growth.

These questions will help you evaluate whether candidates have the relevant experience and expertise. Additionally, consider their track record in meeting or exceeding sales targets (their prior quota attainment), their ability to build rapport with clients, and their problem-solving skills. By answering these questions, you can create a comprehensive job description that accurately reflects the qualities you are looking for, and one that candidates will resonate with.

Create an attractive company culture

A desirable company culture is a significant factor in attracting top sales talent. Candidates want to work for a company that values their employees, offers opportunities for growth and development, and has a positive work environment. Make sure you are highlighting these aspects of your company culture during the recruitment process. You can do this by sharing stories about your company values, employee success stories, and any benefits or perks you offer. It’s also best practice to include this information on the job description and your website.

Remember, with top talent, you are selling them on working for you as much as they are selling you on their ability to deliver results.

Conduct thorough interviews

Conducting thorough interviews is critical when you are recruiting top sales talent. Use a structured interview process that includes both behavioral and situational questions to evaluate candidates' skills and experience. Also, be sure to ask questions that will uncover candidates' work ethic, personality, and communication skills. These are all essential qualities for a successful salesperson.

Additionally, consider asking thought-provoking questions such as:

  1. How do you identify and generate leads?
  2. Can you tell me about the source of your pipeline at your last job? Was it primarily inbound leads, or did you actively hunt for new opportunities?
  3. How do you approach building relationships with prospects and clients? Can you give an example of a successful relationship you've developed in the past?
  4. How do you handle objections or rejections from prospects? Can you share a challenging situation you encountered and how you overcame it?
  5. Can you describe a time when you had to navigate a complex sales process involving multiple decision-makers? How did you manage the situation?
  6. In your previous sales roles, how did you stay motivated during slower periods or when faced with tough targets?
  7. Tell me about a time when you had to adapt your sales approach to meet the needs of a particular client or industry. What steps did you take?
  8. How do you prioritize your sales activities and manage your time effectively to ensure you meet your targets?
  9. How do you stay informed about industry trends and changes that may impact your sales efforts?
  10. What CRM or sales tools do you use, and how do you leverage them to track and measure your pipeline?
  11. What metrics do you believe are essential for tracking and evaluating sales performance?
  12. How do you collaborate with other teams, such as marketing or customer service, to ensure a successful sales outcome?

These thought-provoking questions will help you gain insights into the candidate's experience, problem-solving abilities, and adaptability. They will also provide you with a deeper understanding of their approach to sales and the alignment within your organization.

Going beyond the Interview

While these interview questions can provide valuable insights, incorporating practical exercises into the hiring process can take your evaluation to the next level. These exercises not only allow hiring managers to observe candidates in action but also give candidates a chance to demonstrate their sales prowess firsthand. So, what are some of the best practical exercises to give to sales reps during an interview process?

  • Role Play - This exercise involves creating a simulated sales situation where the candidate assumes the role of a sales representative and the interviewer acts as a potential client or customer. By presenting the candidate with a realistic scenario, such as handling objections or closing a deal, interviewers can assess their ability to think on their feet, communicate persuasively, and adapt to challenging situations. This exercise not only provides valuable insight into the candidate's sales techniques but also offers a glimpse into their problem-solving skills, confidence, and overall approach to customer interactions.
  • Write a Sales Email – Strong copywriting skills are essential for sales and marketing roles. This exercise involves the candidate selecting a person they believe would be a good fit prospect for your product/solution, and then drafting a sales email to engage that specific buyer.  

Offer a competitive compensation package

Top sales talent is in high demand, so make sure you are offering a competitive compensation package that includes both salary and commission. Research salaries in your industry and offer a package that is comparable to or better than your competitors. Pave is an excellent real-time source of compensation information and RepVue offers data specifically tailored to the sales industry. These platforms can offer valuable insights into benchmarks to help you ensure that your compensation package is competitive and attractive to top sales professionals.


Recruiting top sales talent is an ongoing process that can require time, effort, and resources. By defining your ideal candidate, using your network, creating an attractive company culture, conducting thorough interviews, and offering a competitive compensation package, you can increase your chances of finding the best people for your sales team. Remember that building a successful sales team takes time and effort, but with the right approach, you can achieve your goals and grow your business.

Ready to recruit top sales talent and build a winning sales team? Amplify offers Recruiting Services that can support your go-to-market workforce growth. We understand the unique requirements of sales roles and we leverage our extensive network to connect you with exceptional candidates. Connect with us to schedule a strategy call and learn more.